Hello guys! I am extremely happy to judge all of your works and amazed at how talented you all are. Keep it up!! :)

Here are the results for round 1 of this graphic war:

-DemonMoonlight

Use of elements: 14/15

Cleanliness: 9/10

Originality: 14/15

Relevance to the prompt: 5/5

Overall design: 5/5

TOTAL: 47/50

This was very well done considering that it accurately reflects the given prompt, including the theme of fantasy. I especially liked your use of the lilies in this – it is very creative. I think my only feedback is to make the subtitle a bit smaller. But overall, this was a great entry!

AND

wintaeberries

Use of elements: 14/15

Cleanliness: 9/10

Originality: 14/15

Relevance to the prompt: 5/5

Overall design: 5/5

TOTAL: 47/50

I am in love with this cover – I think it perfectly reflects the prompt I gave with the whole rich house, the garden and Sophia being a maid. I also thought the fonts chosen were great and everything on the cover can be easily read. It also gives the fantasy theme which I am happy about it. The only thing is perhaps removing the quotations from the subtitle would be better. Aside from that, very well done cover!

-stainedroses

Use of elements: 14/15

Cleanliness: 9/10

Originality: 13/15

Relevance to the prompt: 5/5

Overall design: 5/5

TOTAL: 46/50

This was extremely done well considering that all the elements were used effectively and the cover accurately reflects the prompt and especially reflects the theme of fantasy. The font type was well chosen but perhaps the title was a bit hard to read. But other than that, well done!

treasure-maker

Use of elements: 13/15

Cleanliness: 9/10

Originality: 13/15

Relevance to the prompt: 5/5

Overall design: 5/5

TOTAL: 45/50

I really liked your use of the elements on your graphic and thought they were appropriate for the prompt. I especially like your font choice as it really supported the genre and the plot! My only feedback is maybe the lily flower could have been a little better shown. Very nice design though!

DarkAngelGraphics

Use of elements: 12/15

Cleanliness: 9/10

Originality: 10/15

Relevance to the prompt: 4/5

Overall design: 4/5

TOTAL: 44/50

This was really well done in the sense that it was made appropriately for the plot. It captured the fantasy genre. The elements were put together nicely. My feedback would be to perhaps use the lily element a bit more creatively. But other than that, it was nicely done. 

AND

BrendaDaaeDestler

Use of elements: 14/15

Cleanliness: 8/10

Originality: 13/15

Relevance to the prompt: 5/5

Overall design: 4/5

TOTAL: 44/50

I especially liked your thought process going into this which resulted in a high originality score – the inclusion of the maid outfit was great and the cover in general accurately reflects the prompt given. I think that my username could have been a bit smaller as it does overpower the title. I also liked your use of the lilies. Well done!

__

Congratulations to the winners, but also well done everyone! Since cherryreh, probablynotkay_, and Moonwatcher132 did not submit their entries, they are automatically eliminated. You guys may PM me for the participant sticker now if you would like.

If anyone would like their feedback and score from me, please do not hesitate and PM me and I will get back to you with them as soon as I can.

Round 2 will be posted in a few hours, so look out for that!! :D