Chapter eleven
Swimming Pool
Penny's POV:
I purposely made sure that Oceana drove me home from school instead of Klitz. God, he looked so good today. The cold weather made his cheeks pink and his nose bright red. The two of us didn't want to be away from each other because it was so cold. "God, it's cold." Klitz shivered as we stood outside. Eli nodded in agreement and said "my fucking balls are gonna fall off." Matt rolled his eyes and said "it's not that cold." "Feels like it." Eli crossed his arms over his chest. Klitz shrugged in agreement and I wrapped my arms around him. Klitz immediately put his arm around my waist and pulled me close, his hand resting on my hip. "Keep me warm, Klitzy." I buried my face into his chest. I hummed softly as I thought about the way he held me close this morning. And for the majority of the day. I quickly closed my door and locked it, pulling my jeans off. I then started to rub my clit over my panties. I leaned back against the pillows on my bed as I imagined it was Klitz's hand in between my legs. His long skinny fingers rubbing at my clit as he kissed my neck. "Mmm, Klitz." I moaned. If I'm being honest I didn't remember the last time I had got myself off. Whenever I was horny Chase and I would just have sex. Now I didn't have him and it had been a couple of weeks since Chase and I had sex last. Lewd images ran through my head as the pleasure inside of me began to slowly build. I knew Klitz was a virgin. The thought of me being his first made me go crazy. And from the way he moaned when we danced together, he had whiny high pitched moans. Which I thought was unbelievably hot. I rolled my eyes as my fingers weren't doing the trick. I grabbed one of my pillows and straddled it, feeling the soft but hard material in between my legs. I moved my hips back and forth slowly, imagining it was Klitz's crotch. Klitz's large hands would be on my hips, guiding me back and forth. His lips would part in awe and his glasses would slide down his nose. A soft moan left my lips as I moved my hips faster. God, what would Klitz think if he knew what I was doing right now? He'd probably freak out. He'd be weirded out and most likely wondering why I was spending time thinking about him. The memory of us dancing floated around in my head. He had squeezed my hips so hard that night there was a slight bruise. I loved it. I loved how he had left a mark on me. My mind then wandered back to the night when we played truth or dare. The kiss Klitz and I shared. Even though it was a drunken kiss, I loved how it felt. He was inexperienced and wasn't sure how to kiss properly but he learned pretty quickly. By now I had reached a steady pace, humping my pillow like it was the last thing I'd do. I could feel my thighs begin to cramp. "Ohhh, Klitz. I'm almost there! Help me cum. I need you to guide me." My clit dragged across the pillow at a perfect angle. I could feel a very thin layer of sweat appearing on my skin from all the movement. The rope inside me. It was so close to snapping. It was hanging on by a thread. "Klitz, please. Please. I need to cum. I need to cum so bad." My voice was desperate as I took in a breath of air. My hips went a little bit faster and that's when the moans of pleasure left my mouth. "Klitz! Klitz! Klitz! Oh, god! You feel so good!" I stopped moving my hips and could feel the cramps in my legs getting worse. I quickly laid on my stomach, stretching my legs out. The pillow still laid in between my legs as I caught my breath. "Oh, Klitz." I whispered. My eyes fluttered closed as I came down from my high. I felt sleep creep up into my body. I slightly felt guilty about getting off to the thought of Klitz but at same time didn't. It's not like he'd find out.

-

The next day at school was colder than yesterday. "F-Fuck." Klitz mumbled. Matt shook his head and said "I should've worn a heavier jacket." Eli currently had a blanket wrapped around his shoulders, his jacket underneath. "I was taking no chances." Eli said. I wished I had Chase's heavy varsity jacket to keep me warm but I was currently wearing one of Klitz's. He had brought an extra sweatshirt for me while he wore his signature gray jacket. I clung to Klitz as we stood by his car. "Why'd we get to school extra early today?" Eli groaned. "Cause of testing. I can't fail these tests." Klitz told Eli. "They're not exams so we're ok. It's just chemistry and English, right?" Matt said. Klitz nodded and said "yeah. It's the end of the quarter so these tests determine my grade." "What's your grades right now?" I asked. "An A." Eli scoffed and said "why are you even stressing? You already have an A. In both classes!" "I still have to pass the tests." Klitz said as he rolled his eyes. I watched the popular girls practically freeze since they were all trying to look cute. "They're going to freeze because they want to look cute. I don't give a damn. I have to be warm." I said. Klitz wrapped his arm around my waist and held me close to him. "After the tests we should skip." Matt said. Eli clicked his tongue and said "skip class? Yeah I have some stuff to do for the yearbook." "Come on, guys. Let's do something fun for once. We're seniors." Matt tried to get his best friends to loosen up a bit. Klitz shook his head and said "I can't afford to have missing work." Matt looked at me and I said "I have those same tests as Klitz." Matt groaned and said "you guys suck." Eli quirked an eyebrow and said "and you swallow, Matt." Matt pushed him out of his way as he started walking towards the school. A harsh gust of wind blew and Eli shuddered. I hid my face in Klitz's chest as he started to walk. "It's cold!" I yelped. Klitz sniffled and I watched his cheeks start to turn pink. His nose was red and I watched his hair blow everywhere. Once we got inside the building, heat started to envelop our bodies. I held onto Klitz's arm as he walked to his locker. I watched Klitz put in his locker combination and open it up. "Did you study?" He said. I nodded against his chest and he grabbed his notes, quickly looking over them. "Hey, you studied a long time for this test. You got this. You're the smartest person I know." I said. Klitz looked at me with a half smile. He nodded and said "you're right. And keep my sweatshirt for today. I know how easily you get cold." "Are you sure you won't need it?" Klitz chuckled and said "Pen, I've got this." He pulled on the gray jacket he wore. "Is that enough. Are you sure you're warm?" I pulled away so I could look at him properly. His nose was starting to go back to it's normal color but his cheeks were still pink. He looked so cute. Klitz pushed his glasses up his nose and said "I'm good. I'm warm. I'm more worried about you, Pen." "I'm ok. Especially now that I have your sweatshirt!" Klitz smiled and said "sure." I hugged him and said "it's so cold. I just wanna stay close to you." Eli stared at the two of us and said "Klitz isn't the warmest out of all of us. I'm pretty sure I'm warmer. I have a blanket." Klitz's arms went around me and I heard him sigh softly. "That may be true but I don't see you hugging me and keeping me warm." "I would have!" I stuck my tongue out at Eli who scoffed. "You always play favorites with Klitz." I shook my head and said "Klitz just takes care of me." "Oh." Klitz's small voice said. I looked up at him and said "right?" "Y-Yeah." "Whatever. I'm going to class. Have fun hugging each other and being all kissy!" Eli said loudly as he walked away. Matt clicked his tongue and said "I'll see you guys." Klitz's blush on his cheeks got deeper and I pulled away from him. "I hope I'm not embarrassing you." Klitz shook his head at me and said "n-no. You're not. It's just...Eli. You know how he is." "Yeah. He's obnoxious." Klitz laughed and I did the same, the two of us going to class.

-

After Matt's desperate attempts to get his friends to skip school, Oceana suggested we all go to her house. She had a pool. Which was heated. She said we could all go swimming and that her parents were gone for the night. Matt was immediately down for it. "Are you sure it's heated?" Klitz asked. Oceana nodded and said "of course. It's my pool." "Yeah, what're you worried about, Klitz?" Eli quipped. "I'm worried about being in freezing cold water." Klitz snapped. Matt shook his head and said "even if it was cold, we could jump in and get out." "I won't go in if it's cold. I hate cold pools." I said. "Guys, it's not gonna be cold! We can play truth or dare like at Penny's." Oceana said to everyone. My mind went back to when we played truth or dare a few weeks ago. The kiss Klitz and I shared. I could feel myself getting wet just by thinking about it. I crossed my leg over the other, my eyes going to Lizzie as she started to tell everyone to bring a bathing suit. "Knowing you guys, you'll wear something skimpy. Especially Penny." Eli said with a smirk. "What's that supposed to mean?" I asked. "Nothing bad. Just that you have a nice body. So you should definitely wear a nice suit." I nodded and a cool breeze came in from the open lunch room windows. I scooted closer to Klitz who seemed to do the same. "What time should we be at yours?" Matt said. "6:30?" Oceana looked at everyone as she said the time. I nodded and Klitz did the same. Eli told her that was fine and then everything was set. I was slightly nervous about tonight. Eli had made that comment about my chest some time ago. I hated it. But then he said I had a nice body. It didn't make sense. I also knew Eli was a very horny eighteen year old boy who couldn't wait to have sex. It was on his mind all the time. The word was practically branded into the front of his brain. The boys hadn't seen me in a bathing suit, in person, in a while now. We hadn't gone to the beach in a long time and we barely went swimming when we hung out. Most of the time we were at mine or Eli's. Those were the designated spots we'd hang out at. And neither of us had a pool. Plus Eli never wanted to go swimming. I was just hoping tonight would go well with no embarrassment. I didn't want the tripod to be embarrassed and I didn't want to be embarrassed. Time would only tell.

-

We were all sitting at Oceana's. None of us had changed into our suits yet. We were all sitting and playing truth or dare. I was currently laying in between Eli's legs. His arms were wrapped loosely around my waist. I had changed into a pair of cotton shorts and a sweater. I watched Klitz's eyes go to my thighs every few seconds. "Truth or dareeee!" Eli said to Lizzie. "You already know I'm picking dare." She quipped. "I dare you to flash me." "Ew, no, you asshole." "Lizzie, please!" "No, Eli pick a better dare." "Whatever. Someone else go since Lizzie doesn't wanna show her tits." Eli pulled me against his body and tightened his arms around my waist. I watched Klitz take a shot of fireball and then say "Matt, truth or dare." "Truth." Matt said. Klitz wiped his mouth with the back of his hand. "Who's the last girl you kissed?" Eli chuckled and Oceana quirked an eyebrow at him. "God, um, Ashley Brock I think." "Ugh, Ashley Brock?!" Eli yelled. Klitz winced and said "that's rough." "Oh, yeah? Who's the last girl you kissed, Klitz." Klitz pointed at me with a smirk. "Penny Lane, baby." He took another shot and I winked at Klitz playfully. "You guys suck." "You're the one who sucks, Matt. You haven't kissed a girl since last year?" Eli quipped. "Uh, you haven't kissed a girl since freshman year. So, who's the one that should be more embarrassed? You. Not me." "I'm just glad I've kissed a girl this year. One of the hottest girls in school too. It must be awful for you guys." Klitz boasted. Alcohol definitely gave him confidence. I liked it. I wished he was more confident. It wasn't a sight I was used to seeing but it made him so so hot. So incredibly hot. "Penny, Pen, Pen." Oceana said. I looked at her and said "dare." Oceana had a wild smirk on her face. My best friend could be so devious sometimes. "I dare you and Klitz to go skinny dipping in the pool." Klitz choked and my eyes widened. Eli's hands started to go up my shirt. "Stop!" I said as I removed him from me. Eli laughed and said "come on, Penny. It's just Klitz." Matt looked at Eli and said "if she doesn't want to, she doesn't have to." "She said dare. She has to." Lizzie said. Klitz looked at me and said "we don't have to." "Don't be such a pussy. Do it." Eli said as he rolled his eyes. Klitz looked at Eli and said "shut up." I scoffed at Eli and said "want me to do it? I will." Klitz's eyes were wide and he said "Pen..." "Let's go." I grabbed Klitz's wrist and pulled him away from the group. "We'll give you guys five minutes! And we'll stay inside!" Oceana said. I pulled Klitz outside and into the backyard. I could see the steam radiating off the pool. "Let's not and say we did." I told Klitz. "Yeah. I guess." He replied with a shrug. I shook my head and said "I'm sure you don't want to see me naked anyways." Klitz looked at me and said "I just don't want you to do something you're not comfortable with." "Klitz, I'm perfectly aware it's weird cause we're friends. It's fine." "No, fuck that. Let's do it." I furrowed my eyebrows and he gestured to the pool. "Fuck it." He started pulling his clothes off. He threw his signature gray jacket onto a lawn chair and started pulling his shoes off. I watched as he fumbled with his belt. "Fuck." He mumbled. Klitz pulled harshly on his belt, tossing it on the ground. The zipper on his khaki pants almost broke from the way he hurried to pull them off. My legs were currently getting stabbed by the cold air since I was in shorts. Klitz set his pants with his jacket and then looked at me. "Come on." A small smirk appeared on my face. The fireball was bringing his confidence back. I slowly took off the thigh high socks I wore and then the shorts. Klitz's eyes went to green lace panties I wore. His lips parted and his hands slowly went in front of his crotch. I turned around to give him a view of my ass as I took off my sweater. I then unclasped my bra. I looked over my shoulder and Klitz stood in his underwear. "You can go in the water first. I won't look." I told him. Klitz nodded and I heard a shuddering breath leave his lips. The sound of water sloshing softly entered the air. "Ok." He said in a small voice. I still had my panties on my hips. I turned to face him, my hands covering my tits. "Like what you see, Klitzy?" I asked in a seductive tone. His eyes were wide and his hands were covering his dick. I giggled and Klitz said "I uh, I won't look as you come in." He turned around slowly, his back to me. I took my panties off and slowly waded into the warm water. Love Rollercoaster started to play from the speakers around Oceana's pool. I rolled my eyes and said "you can look, Klitz." The dark water was covering my chest and Klitz looked at me. His cheeks were pink and he kept his hands in front of his crotch. "I won't look." I reassured him. Klitz shrugged and said "I know. I'm just absolutely terrified right now." "Don't be. It's just me." Klitz nodded and half smiled. I smiled at him and said "I never thought in a million years you'd do something like this." Klitz shook his head and said "me neither." The both of us laughed and I said "what's the craziest thing you've done lately?" "This. I've never done anything this crazy in my entire life. My heart's beating so fast right now I think I might have a heart attack." Klitz said as he ran a wet hand through his hair. "You're living, Klitz." He shrugged and said "yeah. I guess I am." I laughed softly and Klitz looked down while smiling really big. "CANNONBALL!!" Eli screamed as he jumped into the pool. He purposely landed right next to Klitz who yelled in terror. "Eli, get away from me!" Matt followed suit and I said "GUYS DONT LOOK!" Eli came up for air, his dark hair sitting on top of his head. "Penny, give me a tit shot!" "No!" I covered my chest and was grateful the pool light wasn't on. "Alright, the dare's over. Come on, Penny." Oceana said as she gestured for me to come over to where she stood outside of the pool. "Go ahead, Penny. We won't look." Matt told me. Eli smirked up at me and Klitz covered Eli's eyes. "Klitz, what're you doing! Oh my god, you're naked!" "Shut up! You can't look at her!" I took my chance and got out of the pool, wrapping a towel around me. I grabbed my clothes and started heading inside so I could change into my bathing suit. "Klitz, if your dick touches me-" "Quit thrashing around and it won't." Klitz retorted. Oceana and Lizzie followed me so Klitz could grab his swimming trunks. "Did you see his dick?" Lizzie asked me as we stood in the bathroom. I shook my head and said "no. I only saw the outline from his briefs." "Oh god, he wears briefs?!" Lizzie started laughing and Oceana said "did it look big?" I shrugged and said "I couldn't exactly stare at it. I didn't want to make him uncomfortable." "Did he see your vagina?" "No! God, you guys!" The two of them laughed and I had finished putting my one piece bathing suit on. The three of us went back outside to see Eli holding Klitz's glasses while laughing. "Give them back, fucker!" Klitz grabbed Eli who yelped in fear. Klitz snatched his glasses from Eli who was pushed underwater by Matt. "Matt!" He came up coughing while Matt laughed. Eli then pushed Matt underwater to get revenge. "Ha! How does it feel?!" Klitz rolled his eyes and then looked up at me. "Hi, Penny." He waved up at me with a smile. "Hi, Klitz." I waved back, a big smile appearing on my face. I got in the water and said "are you more comfortable now?" Klitz nodded and said "yeah." "Me too. But I'm glad we did the dare." "Same. For some reason it felt exhilarating. I've never really done stuff like that before." "Me neither." Eli did a backflip into the pool and Oceana said "Eli, if you crack your head open I'm not gonna he happy." "Seriously. You're stressing me out." I added. Eli rolled his eyes and said "I'm fine. Nothing will happen to me." "I'm cold." I said. Klitz looked to the hot tub and said "wanna go over there?" I nodded and the two of us made our way over to the hot tub. "Too cold for you guys?" Eli asked. "Very!" I replied. I turned on the switch and the bubbles came on. I stepped into the hot water and immediately felt so much better. The pool wasn't too cold but I needed to be warm. Klitz stepped in next to me, sitting in the corner furthest away. "Mmm." Klitz moaned as the hot water engulfed his body. I wanted to comment but didn't want to embarrass him. It seemed as if he remembered I was only sitting a few feet away from him. I acted like I was staring up at the sky and then looked back at him. "Why're you all the way over there?" I said to him. He shrugged and said "I dunno. I didn't want to make it weird." "It's not weird." I scooted closer to him and he tensed up. "You didn't see my dick, did you?" Klitz looked at me with a fearful look on his face. I shook my head. "No. I didn't. I purposely didn't look. You didn't see my cunt did you?" Klitz winced at the word and said "Penny, don't say that word." "Well what do you want me to say? Vagina?" "I mean, it's what it's called. Cunt is so crude." I giggled softly and said "did you see it?" "No, I didn't. I wasn't gonna look unless you wanted to see it." "Did you look at my tits?" Klitz exhaled deeply and said "I mean...a little. I couldn't really see them." I nodded and looked over at Eli who was on Matt's back. Lizzie and Oceana were swimming away from them, the two of them in their own world. "If I don't get into Yale, we'll still be friends, right?" Klitz looked at me and said "of course. But, why wouldn't you get into Yale?" "I don't know. It's a lot of work. I don't feel like I'm smart enough." I looked down at the water and felt tears brimming my eyes. I'd never want Klitz to put his future on hold for me. And we weren't even together but I wanted the best for him. I wanted him to have everything he wanted. "Pen, look at me." I looked up at Klitz who said "I'll help you. No matter what. We'll study like crazy if we have to. I know how much you want to go to Yale. I'll make sure you get there." He took my hands in his and then said "I promise." I chuckled softly and said "you don't have to." "You're my best friend. I want you to be happy too. You deserve it." I hugged Klitz and he said "o-oh." I buried my face into the crook of his neck and said "thank you." "You're welcome." He replied. His hand moved slowly up and down my back. I scooted even closer to him, our legs touching as I hugged him tighter. My chest was pressed up against his and I felt his arms tighten around me. I then slowly pulled away, my arms still around his neck. I kissed his cheek, making sure to kiss the corner of his lips. "Thanks, Klitzy." "N-No problem." I removed myself from him and felt his arms fall from my waist. "What's going on over here, lovebirds?" Eli asked. "Nothing. Just talking." I replied. "Mind if I join you?" "Yeah." Klitz said but Eli got into the hot tub anyways. "I brought you guys each a shot." I took it from Eli and downed the fiery liquid. Klitz did the same and exhaled. "You guys should let me film you making out." Eli suggested. Klitz furrowed eyebrows and said "what?" "Yeah. Like the hot popular girl and the nerdy guy are sitting in a hot tub talking. They're both drunk and just start making out. Let me film it. Please!" I shook my head and said "no, Eli. That's weird." I didn't want Klitz to be uncomfortable especially after I knew he wasn't into me. "Please, Klitz! You know you want this! Penny, I swear nothing will happen! It'll be just kissing!" Eli begged. "Dude, no. That's fake. We're not together." Klitz said in a weird tone. "So? Nobody who makes porn is actually together! The majority of them just fuck for the camera!" Eli replied. "Eli, I don't want to. Just stop." Klitz was sitting up now, staring Eli down. "Fine. Whatever." Eli put his hands up in defense. I stood up and made my way out of the hot tub, going back to the pool with Oceana and Lizzie. Matt had walked over to talk to his friends. "Klitz, come on!" Eli whisper yelled. "No, dude! Stop!" Klitz said. A few minutes later we all got out of the pool and went back inside. I changed back into my clothes and I could feel the alcohol making me unbelievably tired. I stumbled a little as I came out of the bathroom. "Woah." Klitz's voice said. His hand was on my waist, holding me up. I looked up at him and said "I'm sorry." "No, it's ok. It seems like I'm always taking care of you when you're drunk." I shrugged and said "you're the best at it." Klitz was still shirtless and in his swimming trunks. "I gotta change and then I can take you home." My hands were on his chest for support and I nodded. "Ok." I went back to the living room and awaited Klitz to be done getting dressed. Matt had driven with Eli so the two of them already left. I told Oceana and Lizzie goodbye who were going upstairs to have sex. When Klitz was finished he came out of the bathroom, fumbling with his pants. "Stupid." He was messing with the zipper and managed to pull it up. He held his belt in the other hand and I said "didn't feel like putting the belt on?" "No. Too tired." I nodded and the two of us got in his car, going towards my house. The drive was mostly silent except for the radio playing softly. When we pulled up to my house, Klitz walked me to the door as he always did. I unlocked my door and he gave me a quick hug before going to walk away. I then grabbed his arm and he turned around to look at me with a furrowed brow. "Stay the night with me?" I asked hopefully. Klitz gulped and looked at the watch on his wrist. He then looked at me, then his car, then back at me. "Fuck it." He locked his car and followed me inside the house. The two of us went upstairs to my bedroom and he said "are your parents here?" "Yeah?" "I can't sleep with you." "Yes, you can. Come on." I pulled him into my bedroom and closed the door. I locked it and pulled off his jacket. His eyes went slightly wide and I said "relax. I'm just taking your jacket off. I threw it on a chair and then pulled him to my bed. I leaned my head on his shoulder as the two of us got under the covers. "Thanks for staying the night with me." I whispered. "You're welcome." He said. I nuzzled my face into the crook of his neck and then wrapped my arms around him. The warmth of his body was lulling me to sleep and I could barely hold my eyes open. "Goodnight, Penny." I hummed and said "goodnight, Klitz." The last thing I felt before I fell asleep was Klitz's arm going around my waist.

Wowowow I was supposed to have this up days ago but didn't🙃
~skylar💗🫧💗🫧