Chapter twenty one
Klitzy's First Time
Penny's POV:
I stood next to Klitz as I watched people swarm outside towards the pool area to party. I munched on one of the cookies Klitz and I had made and he reached for one. He grabbed a sugar cookie with sprinkles and he watched Eli dance with Ferrari. I bopped my head to the rap song that was currently blasting. As I finished my cookie I pulled on Klitz's hand, leading him to the pool area. I rolled my eyes at the fact Hunter was here with Chase. I had locked the majority of the doors in the house except for the bathrooms. I didn't want anyone messing around in my house. Oceana and Lizzie were dancing together. I just hoped nobody would end up jumping into the pool. I turned to Klitz as Around the World started to play. "Can we?" He nodded and I brushed a few sprinkles from the corner of his lips. I pulled him to where everyone was dancing. I started to grind on him, letting the beat of the music move my body. Klitz guided me slowly, letting me do most of the work. Soft moans and whimpers left his lips. I smirked to myself and ground against him harder. "P-Penny." Klitz said as he leaned his head on my shoulder. I felt a slight hardness as I continued to grind against him. My hand reached up to the back of his neck, my hand running down his body. Klitz squeezed my hips and Eli walked around with his camera. I flipped him off as he started to film us like had a couple of months before. "Love you too!" Eli yelled as he moved on to film other people. As the song slowly came to an end, Klitz turned me around to face him. "Can we....uh...g-go up to your room?" He asked. I bit my lip and said "sure." I led Klitz away from the large crowd and towards the house. "Penny, do you have a spare key for the guest bedroom?" Oceana asked me. I nodded and went inside the house to grab Oceana a spare key. I handed it to her and she looked at me and Klitz. "Don't do anything I wouldn't do." She said. Klitz put his hands in his pockets while blushing. He looked down while smiling. "You do the same, bestie." I told Oceana. I pulled Klitz up the stairs and towards my room. I unlocked the door with my key and the two of us went inside my room. I locked the door and the music boomed below us. The pool was directly outside my window. Klitz ran a hand through his hair and sat on my bed. The fairy lights in my room gave off the right amount of light. I went to sit next to Klitz and he slowly leaned in, kissing my lips. I smiled into the kiss and cupped his cheek. I slowly kicked off my heels as I laid back. Klitz tried to kick off his dress shoes but had to stop kissing me to untie them. He huffed as he undid them and threw them towards my closet. He laid down next to me and the two of us started to kiss again. Klitz kissed me feverishly as I pulled on his tie, bringing him closer to me. I slowly swung my leg over his lap, going to straddle him. I sat down on his lap gently, Klitz groaning softly. I could feel his dick poking my crotch. He had already been hard downstairs but it seemed like he was harder now. I slowly started to grind my hips against his. I pulled away from him, using his chest for support as I started a steady pace. Klitz's eyes were screwed shut and trembling breaths left his lips. He gripped handfuls of the fluffy pink comforter that laid beneath us. "You know you can touch me, Klitzy." He nodded and said "uh-huh." I brushed his bangs out of his face, cupping his cheek as I laid down. I pressed a sweet kiss to his lips and Klitz chased after the kiss as I pulled away. Klitz's eyes fluttered open and his lips parted. "Touch me, Klitz. Please." Klitz's hands went to my hips, slowly guiding me back and forth. "Oh, Klitz." I felt him twitch underneath me, his eyes going wide. "S-Stop. Stop. Stop." He quickly said. I stopped moving and said "what's wrong?" He exhaled shakily and he slowly removed me from his lap. Klitz smacked his lips and said "I, uh...I was about to cum. I didn't wanna cum in my pants." "Have you?" I said. Klitz furrowed his eyebrows. "Cum in my pants?" I nodded. "Yeah. Once or twice." I stood up and said "do you want to have sex with me?" Klitz looked absolutely flabbergasted as he looked at me. I went to open my mouth and he said "yeah. Fuck yeah, I do." I smiled and said "could you unzip my dress?" I turned around and heard Klitz stand up. I awaited him to unzip me, nerves bubbling up in my stomach. I felt the zipper move down my back and I knew Klitz was going to see my thong I currently wore. I held the dress so it wouldn't fall on the floor and I laid it on a chair in my bedroom. I stood in my bra and panties. Klitz's eyes went to my pink thong which had a bedazzled heart on the front. "That's hot." He mumbled. I took my hair out of the clip it was in, shaking it out. "Why am I the only one undressed?" I teased. Klitz undid his tie and took off his sport coat, setting it on the other chair I had in my bedroom. He fumbled with his belt and the zipper of his dress pants. He took off his vest and button up shirt. I'd seen Klitz shirtless multiple times before. This wasn't anything new. Klitz shuffled off his pants and now stood in his boxers. I slowly reached up to take off my bra. Klitz's lips parted and he struggled to form words. He was definitely a boob guy. I went to sit on my bed and Klitz followed me. His eyes were glued to my chest and he hesitated in reaching out to touch me. I grabbed his hands and put them on my tits. Klitz's eyes fluttered closed as he kneaded them in his hands. I moaned as I felt my nipples getting hard. The feeling of them rubbing up against Klitz's hands made me squeeze my thighs to relieve a little bit of the pressure. Klitz kissed my neck up and down as his hands roamed my body. I ran my fingers through his hair, holding him close to me as he started to suck a hickey on my neck. He was careful and precise as he licked over the hickey, making sure I wasn't in any pain. "Paid attention to Ferrari's lesson, huh?" I said. Klitz looked up at me and nodded. He slowly went down to my chest, attaching his lips to my right breast. I gasped and jumped at the feeling. Klitz immediately stopped and said "are you ok?" I nodded and said "yeah. Just a new feeling. It feels good." Klitz half smiled and maintained eye contact as he started to suck on my tit again. I moaned and my hand started to trail down to my panties, rubbing over the fabric. Klitz kissed my chest up and down before moving to the other breast. I threw my head back as Klitz pulled off me with a pop. Klitz looked down at my hand rubbing at my clit. "Do you have a condom?" I asked him. Klitz nodded and scrambled to get to his pants. I took that opportunity to take off my panties. When Klitz turned around, he saw I was completely naked in front of him. His mouth dropped and I motioned for him to come over to the bed. He sat back down in front of me and he reached in between my legs. He moaned as I spread my legs for him. Klitz ran his fingers up my slit, chuckling in disbelief. "You're really wet." "All for you, Klitz." He slowly stood up to take off his boxers. He avoided eye contact with me as he was now naked in front of me. I exhaled and said "you're big." "I am?" "Yeah. You're hung, Klitz." He half smiled and opened up the condom. I watched him slide it onto his dick. "April taught you well, I see." I teased. Klitz shook his head and said "I already knew how. I've just never done it." I went to lay down and I spread my legs again, inviting Klitz to start whenever he was ready. Klitz positioned himself in between my legs and looked down. He ran the head of his dick up and down my slit. "W-What if it's not good?" Klitz said in a nervous tone. I cupped his cheek and said "hey, it's your first time. I'm not expecting you to be the best. I want to be your first, Klitz." Klitz nodded and pushed himself inside me. I gasped at the stretch and Klitz's lips parted in shock. "Oh, fuck." He said. I removed my hand from his cheek and Around the World was playing for the second time. Klitz furrowed his eyebrows and I said "that's probably Eli's doing." "He knows we're up here?" Klitz asked frantically. I shook my head while laughing softly. "He likes this song. Just like you and I do." Klitz nodded again and said "right." He started to move slowly, gasps and soft moans leaving his lips. "Klitz, you're so big. Holy shit." I said. Klitz started to pick up his pace, his breath quivering. "F-Fuck, Penny. You feel so good. So good. Fuck." "Keep going, Klitz. Harder." "Fuck! Fuck! P-Penny, oh my god." I felt him spill into the condom and he panted. Klitz's face immediately turned red as he realized what happened. He said "I'm sorry. I'm so sorry." I shook my head and said "it's ok." "No it's not. I literally came in ten seconds!" I sat up a little and said "Klitz, it's ok. We can always go again." "W-We can?" I kissed his forehead sweetly and said "of course." Klitz kissed my lips and slowly started to move his hips again. I laid back down against my pillows and Klitz said "I wanna make you cum this time." "I'll tell you how. Ok? Go slow. Don't go too fast." Klitz's thrusts were slow but hard. He bit his lip and his eyes fluttered closed. He leaned down to kiss my neck, practically laying on top of me. I relished in feeling him against me. I wrapped my arms around his neck and Klitz's hands gripped handfuls of the blanket underneath us, burying his face into the crook of my neck. "You're so pretty. You're so pretty, baby." Klitz whimpered. I felt the rope in my stomach start to tighten. "Just like that, Klitz. You're doing good. You're doing so good." I said. Klitz groaned in response and I told him to go faster. Klitz picked up his pace and my hands went to his shoulders. "Penny, I'm going to cum." "Just a little bit longer, Klitz. I'm almost there." He nodded against my neck. I moved my hips against his, trying to get myself there so Klitz could finish. It was like Klitz read my mind as he started to go faster and harder. I gasped and said "fuck. Just like that! Don't stop! Don't stop, Klitz!" His face scrunched up into pleasure as he propped himself back up. The small patch of hair on Klitz's pubic bone was rubbing against my clit perfectly as I moved my hips against him. "I'm almost there, Klitz. God, I'm right there." Klitz whimpered and said "please. Please. I n-need to cum. Penny. Penny, please." There it was. My orgasm hit me like a truck. "I'm cumming! Klitz! Klitz!" His name left my mouth like a mantra and I quickly realized he was finishing at the same time with me. High pitched moans came from Klitz as he had his second orgasm of the night. "Penny! Penny! F-F-Fuck! Fuck! Oh my goddd." Klitz collapsed on top of me. He panted and I reached up to stroke his head. Klitz's breath quivered and his body trembled. "Oh, Klitz." I played with his hair as I coaxed him down from his high. I could hear Eli's screams over the Usher song that was booming below us. Klitz chuckled and slowly sat up. I cupped his cheek and kissed his lips. Klitz slowly pulled out and winced as he did so. I watched him take the condom off, throwing it away in the small trash can in my room. He laid down next to me and sighed. "That was awesome. It was like really great." He was still trying to catch his breath. I sat up and went to get under my covers, I had folded them down before Klitz and I had got down to business. I frowned and Klitz said "baby?" "I guess you don't know much about aftercare." I said softly. "Aftercare?" "Yeah. Most people cuddle after sex or some actually clean each other up in the bathroom. It's definitely apart of it. I feel like." Klitz shifted his body and said "oh. I can cuddle you. Come here." "You don't have to." I told him as I looked down. "Come here." Klitz got under the covers, grabbing me and pulling me on his chest. I nuzzled my face into Klitz's neck and he kissed my forehead. "I love you." He whispered. I looked up at him and said "I love you too." It was quiet for a few minutes except for the loud music downstairs. I traced circles on Klitz's stomach. "You'll stay the night?" I asked. "Of course, Pen." I squeezed Klitz and he spoke up again after a minute. "Was I....bad?" I shook my head and said "no. Not at all. You were great." "Really?" Klitz tried to hide his smile. I nodded and said "yeah. And with practice you'll get better." Klitz exhaled and said "not to be weird but I've always wanted this. I wanted to be your boyfriend for the longest time and obviously have sex with you." I giggled and said "awe, I've always wanted the same." I cupped Klitz's cheek and kissed his lips. "Do you wanna go back downstairs? Maybe party a little bit?" Klitz said. I shook my head and said "could we stay here?" "Yeah. Sure. Uhm, I brought some clothes to spend the night. They're in your closet." Klitz said. I sat up and said "when did you manage to do that?" "Earlier. I drove here before going to Matt's. I wanted to spend the night with you. Whether we did or didn't have sex. I wanted to be here with you." I felt my heart swelling in my chest and I said "Tim, you're so sweet." Klitz sat up and kissed my lips passionately, his hand going to my chest. He kneaded my left breast in his right hand. "Mmm, Klitz, don't." Klitz pulled away and said "why? Can't go for round three?" I laughed in disbelief and said "oh my god! You've had enough for tonight! Stop!" He laughed with me and I shook my head. I stood up and went to change into some sleepwear. I heard Eli's voice in the house and I quickly rushed downstairs as Klitz was getting dressed. "Kick these people out for me, will you?" Eli nodded and said "sure. BITCHES! PARTY'S OVER!" I rushed back upstairs to see Klitz in his pajamas. I closed the door and locked it behind me. I turned out my lamps and the two of us went to lay in my bed. Our legs were entangled and I nuzzled my face into the crook of Klitz's neck. He kissed my head and I could hear the groans of party patrons having to leave. "LETS GO! EVERYONE OUT!" Eli yelled. I figured Eli would go and sleep in the basement when he was finished kicking everyone out. My eyes started to droop. Klitz snored softly and I half smiled. I closed my eyes, allowing sleep to take hold of me.

Oceana's POV:
I smirked to myself as I watched Klitz and Penny go into the house and upstairs. I had the guest bedroom key and walked over to grab my girlfriend. I started to pull her through the crowd of people and upstairs. The two of us practically tore our prom dresses off, heading towards the bed. Lizzie pushed me down gently and said "I'm gonna make you feel good, babe." I took off my panties and Lizzie got in between my legs. She smirked as she licked a stripe up my slit. I gasped and my hands went to her hair. Lizzie hooked her arms under my legs and started fucking me with her tongue. I moaned and tugged on her hair. Lizzie moved up to suck on my clit while using her fingers to fuck me. "Lizzie, just like that. Don't stop." Lizzie sucked harshly and I slowly started to grind against her face. Lizzie went back down and her tongue thrusted in and out of me. Lizzie moaned against me which sent vibrations through my body. "Fuck." I said as the knot in my stomach tightened. Lizzie's grip on my thighs got tighter as her tongue started to move faster. Lizzie lapped at me as if I was her last meal. "Lizzie!" I cried. Lizzie moved back up to my clit, sucking and nibbling softly. Her fingers were inside me once again, moving at a quick pace. "Feel good, babe?" Lizzie asked. I nodded as I wasn't able to speak. Lizzie chuckled softly and said "you're close, aren't you?" "I'm so close. I'm so fucking close, Lizzie." I mewled. "Cum for me, Oceana. Cum for me." Lizzie said with a smirk. I gasped as I came undone. Lizzie's name left my lips as I rode out my orgasm. Lizzie pulled away with a smirk and went to straddle me. Lizzie brushed some of my hair out of my face and started to move her hips. Lizzie moaned softly as her clit rubbed against mine. I moved against her, trying to build up both of our orgasms. I was thankful the music was so loud because Lizzie and I were moaning pretty loud. "Fuck, you looked so good tonight, babe." Lizzie said. I cupped her cheek and kissed her lips. Lizzie's tongue slipped into my mouth and our passionate kissed soon to sloppy ones. Lizzie pulled away to kiss up and down my neck. I would definitely be marked up in the morning. I wrapped my arms around Lizzie's shoulders, keeping her close to me. Lizzie bit down on my neck gently, licking over it with her tongue. I left sweet kisses on her neck and she started to grind against me harder. The new feeling of pressure was about to push me over the edge. "Mmm, fuck, I'm close! Fuck! Fuck!" Lizzie groaned. I continued to move against her, wanting the both of us to come at the same time. Pants left Lizzie's lips as she was getting closer to her release, her thrusts getting sloppy. "Please tell me you're close." I nodded at Lizzie and said "uh huh." Just as Usher's Yeah started playing, the two of us came undone. Lizzie gripped my hips and rode out her orgasm. "Lizzie! Shit! Shit!" "Oh my god, Oceana! Fuck! Oceana, god!" The two of us panted as Lizzie collapsed on top of me. I shifted my body and Lizzie winced. "Don't move. I'm so sensitive." I giggled softly at my girlfriend who was trying to catch her breath. "BITCHES! PARTY'S OVER!" Eli screamed. Lizzie laughed and got off of me, the two of us laying on our backs. I laid my head on her shoulder and she wrapped her arms around me, holding me close to her. "Oceana?" "Yeah?" "I love you. I really do." I looked at my girlfriend in shock. I never thought Lizzie would ever say those words to me. We had filmed together for the longest time and hadn't ever told each other how we felt. I was too worried about making it super awkward or her not wanting to film with me ever again. "I love you too, Lizzie." She kissed my forehead and I covered us with the blanket. Lizzie's breathing got slower and more relaxed. I closed my eyes and stayed close to her, not wanting to be away from her. Having sex on prom night is so cliche but this was the first time Lizzie and I had ever done it with it being passionate. And I was very thankful just to have this moment.

Here's the update!! I hope the smut wasn't too cringe and you all enjoyed this. I'm going to drop my Spotify playlists I listen to while writing this fic lmaoo. One if specifically for Klitz and the other is for Klitz and Eli combined. And y'all can save them if you want or whatever. I made them myself and am quite proud of them
~skylar💕🫧💕🫧