I really need y'all help!!!

So I really want to get into anime, but I can't find any good ones to starts off on.

I already downloaded attack on titan, golden time, and black butler. Oh and the familiar of zero. Haven't watch any of them yet, but I will eventually.

But I have no idea if I'll actually enjoy them or if I'm just going to lose interest like last time.

Actually funny story, Emma suggested golden time and the familiar of zero, thanks emma. And I just google what animes to watch and I some how came a cross a quiz telling which one is perfect for me. I don't know either

So it suggested black butler to me. Oh and I actually seen attack on titan when it first came out. I fell in love with it. I only watch like two or three episodes of it though. Because I was way to young to watch it and if my parents ever caught me, I would me dead.

I mean I can't blame them, so much blood and naked titans running around eating people. But I'm old enough now to watch it!!!

So the whole point of this is because I really need some recommendations.

I know I already have four to watch, but most of them are only a few episodes and knowing me I'll watch one in a day.

   Honestly I love story lines that are super natural. Or just fictional is fine.

   Please tell me some recommendations!!!

*