Author: fhreyachaes 

Blurb:

[BOOK ONE OF MISCHIEF MANAGED SERIES]

"Just look at her, James!" Sirius cried out exasperatedly. "Can't you see it? You're in love with her." 

He shook his head stubbornly. "No, I love Lily." 

 "Get over yourself. It's always been Catherine, Prongs. Just look at her!" And so he did just as Sirius did too. And in that moment, Catherine tipped her head back to laugh at whatever Lily told her, and James realized that it was true. He was in love with a girl he never expected to fall for. But it wasn't only him, Sirius too realized he had fallen for her.

 ««•»» 

 Catherine Valentine had it all. She was exceptionally kind, beautiful, tall, a mischievous prankster, had a loud melodious laugh, belonged to a rich family, could care less about blood status despite being a pureblood, and an exquisite personality everyone loved. Oh, and let's not forget the heart of a certain Marauder. Not one but two Marauders.

Main Romantic Ship: James Potter/Sirius Black x OC

Rating: 9/10

Review: As usual, the sad ending broke me. The book was epic, though. In this book, the OC — Catherine, has to choose between Sirius and James, and both are in love with her. The war in comments is just hilarious. I switched sides from Sirius to James, and back to Sirius, and to James and then back to Sirius and then back to James in a continuous loop. Enjoyed it immensely.