First off choose who you want to be with in this scenario

1. Slenderman - he's kind, caring, compassionate, and will defend you with his life.
-kinks
• slender has a daddy kink, you don't call him daddy you don't get anything
-dislikes
• he dislikes teasing, he gets annoyed very easily. That's why LJ is always in trouble.
-how you guys met
    •slendy saved you from the cops you asked to for sanctuary and he gladly gave if to you. 
2. Jeff the killer- a bit of a dick but none the less loyal. If needed he can pull his head out of his ass and fight for you.
-kinks
• he has a sharp object kink, a sexy night with him is going to result in multiple stab wounds and bandages
-dislikes
• he doesn't like a smart mouth, if you talk back to him prepare ur anus for a rough night.
-how you guys met
    •Jeff almost killed your parents but you agreed to be his servant for as long as you live for sparing your life
3.( my favorite) laughing Jack- fun, loving, companionate, can't take anything seriously, so if you love to party and just have a good old time, he's probably your guy. But never tell him where your stash of candy is.
-kinks
• has a daddy kink, bondage kink, licking kink, biting kink, just think of as many kinks as you can I'm pretty sure he has it.
-dislikes
• rough sex, he hates to hurt you all he wants to do is show you how much he loves you. But that does lead to some scratching and bruising.
-how you guys met
     •you were extremely lonely and had nothing to do so you walked into an old abandoned amusement park and bumped into Jack just after he killed someone. He really liked you because you weren't afraid of him.
4. Eyeless Jack- he's pretty quiet but loving nonetheless. He's very smart and quick witted. He gets annoyed by the other pastas very easily. Him and LJ often fight over who is the better Jack.
-kinks
• EJ has a biting kink, for obvious reasons he wants to taste you...literally
-Dislikes
    • he dislikes to be harassed or teased, try to stay on his good side if you guys make it to the bed
-how you met
    • you woke up when he was taking your kidney, you didn't complain you just expected it since he had numbed you you couldn't feel anything. He took a liking that you weren't frightened by him.
5. Ben drowned- Ben is a perv so if you like that kind of thing then he's for you. He's always high off his dick so I hope you like that too.
-kinks
• he has a bondage kink, he'll purposely get you to your high then fall asleep on you.
-dislikes
• really not much he's pretty chill
-how you met
   •you were playing legend of Zelda majoras mask and it happened to be the haunted cartridge. Henceforth you met Ben drowned.
( I'll add more later on for reasons but for now read all of the info in the guys here. Pick wisely let's hope the one you pick isn't the one that can hold a massive grudge)