For the only REAL female Dark Forest villain, I didn't really like her to much. One thing is she was one of the only cat who had a mate in RiverClan and got in trouble for it. Then ALL her kits die, and her mate blames her for it. I mean most of people's OC backstories just became cannon. Also they way she made Crookedstar promise what he did was just down right stupid! She didn't even hurt Crookedstar, all the stuff that happened to him was just the cycle of life! Not Mapleshade! She could have at least hurt him or something! This character may have had a good backstory but so many things made me question it so much. I mean every other cat who had a mate outside their clan was forgiven! Why not her? Anyway I'm done with her, comment down below the next cat I should do!