Chris Pine as Arthur Morgan

Arthur was the hardest for me to cast. He is the MC after all. I think Chris Pine would be a great choice! Apart from having similar features, Pine is talented and I think he could pull it off.

Liam Hemsworth as John Marston

I wasn't too sure about this at first, but I think Hemsworth could do it!

Lauren Cohan as Abigail Roberts-Marston

Abigail and Lauren look SO much alike. And Lauren is a fantastic actress so I can't picture anyone else as Abigail Roberts

Jeffrey Dean Morgan as Dutch van der Linde

Jeffrey is both charming and terrifying. Just picture him with Dutch's signature mustache.

Domhnall Gleeson as Sean MacGuire

Wes Studi as Rains Fall

Wes is absolutely wonderful in everything he's in. He would make a perfect Rains Fall

David Harbour as Bill Williamson

If David grew out his beard a bit they would look extremely alike. Plus David is awesome and I'd love to see it.

Woody Harrelson as Micah Bell

No explanation needed.

Winston Duke as Charles Smith

Scarlett Johansson as Sadie Adler