...Zodiac signs (the ones in the show)!

Aries: llama
Taurus: glasses
Gemini: shooting star
Cancer: stitched heart
Leo: question mark
Virgo: star/pentagram
Libra: pine tree
Scorpio: fez
Sagittarius: ice bag
Capricorn: six fingered hand

And for the 2 signs excluded above:
Aquarius: Waddles
Pisces: Gompers

I didn't want to leave y'all out