Jacksepticeye:

When Jack cooks he loves to try and be fancy with it, one night he had gotten the idea to and try to make a romantic spaghetti dinner for the two of you. He was boiling the noodles while he was trying to make the sauce, the garlic bread in the oven cooking as well.

When you went over to visit Jack since he had called you, but being board you went a little earlier than expected and you see him laying out the plates and forks at the table. In the end, you two had an amazing meal. But with a little burned garlic bread. 

Antisepticeye:

Anti was cooking some normal hot pockets when you asked him to make you something, which gave him an idea. He wanted to maybe make something for you and him, mostly him because he was starving.

He cut up the hot pockets and tried to fold the hot bread to make it seem fancy, as well of spreading all the sauce and meat on top of the bread to make it seem like it was some sort of ratatouille, In the end, you were confused and told him you just wanted a normal hot pocket. 

Chase:

Chase wanted to make homemade pizza so he made his own pizza batter and toppings! He cut up some sausage and gritted some cheese as well of making his own sauce too. When he was flipping the dough it stuck on top of the ceiling.

Chase grabbed a chair and a small butter knife to try and get the dough off, right when you entered your home Chase got a face of pizza dough in his face as he fell off the chair, groaning in pain as he tried to get the sticky dough off.  You ordered pizza instead.

Dr. Schneeplestein:

Henrik had the day off since it was the weekend, unfortunately, you had a job that forced you to work on the weekends since one of your coworkers called in sick and you were the first one to call, so Henrik wanted to make dinner.  He started to make some simple soup but it ended in hell once it blew into a fire.

He had put too much salt and it burned and set the pot on fire, so he quickly tried to put it out with some water, which only made it worst.  When you finally came home you found Henrik on the couch looking scared. And a burned pot.

Magic Marvin:

Marvin was hungry so he wanted to make a grilled cheese for both of you. He got out the bread and cheese and began to make them, humming a small song to entertain himself. He slowly started to daydream, not paying mind to the grilled cheese.

Marvin finally snapped back at the small of burnt bread, the awful smell around him as he quickly turned off the stove. Gagging at the taste of the smoke.  In the end, you make the grilled cheese.