Steve Rogers-
The Phantom of the Opera

Tony Stark-
Heathers

Bruce Banner-
Wicked

Clint Barton-
Sweeney Todd

Thor Odinson-
Hadestown

Loki Laufeyson-
The Lion King on Broadway

Bucky Barnes-
Grease

Pietro Maximoff-
Mean Girls

Peter Parker-
Dear Evan Hansen

Peter Quill-
Hairspray

Sam Wilson-
Hamilton