"Whoopsie!" Fluttershy giggled, dropping Angel onto the floor. "Pitiful. I knew you wouldn't last as long as the real Angel." Tutting at the small limp figure, Fluttershy kicked it carelessly out of sight. Applejack, for once forgetting she was strapped, became confused. "The real Angel?" Fluttershy laughed menacingly. "I thought you were smart Applejack." She blew out the candle, and the room went dark once more. To Applejack's horror, as the room gained light again, Fluttershy was standing over her with a bloody knife in her hoof. Applejack yet out a yell and Fluttershy staggered back. Fluttershy screamed in rage and plunged the knife deep into Applejack's back hoof. Applejack clenched her teeth as blood flowed freely down her leg, noticing that Fluttershy had cut through the bone; it was beyond repair now. Fluttershy composed herself, taking a deep breath before returning to her victim. "Sorry," she apologised. "I get really mad sometimes." Her pupils slid to the top corner and bottom corner of her eyes, and she motioned a 'coo-coo' by waving her left hoof in circles beside her head before taking her pupils back to the middle of her eyes.

Applejack let out a piercing scream as Fluttershy pulled out the knife stuck in Applejack's hoof. "Shush!" She hissed. "Remember your promise not to tell anypony. Or...." she smiled wickedly. "I might do it again." She put the knife down and picked up a stray shard of glass on the floor Applejack didn't notice before. Applejack wondered what she would do with it. Fluttershy stood up on her two back hooves and held the glass share high in one hoof as she advanced towards Applejack. Applejack shut her eyes tightly as Fluttershy moved closer towards her face. To her surprise, Applejack felt Fluttershy tilt Applejack's head to one side. Her heart broke as she heard the sharp glass cut through her mane onto the floor. Fluttershy bent down towards Applejack's rear to cut off the tail hair.

Draining out all her energy, Applejack emptied her bladder onto Fluttershy. Recoiling, Fluttershy hissed in rage. She shook her mane and unbuckled Applejack's legs. Applejack kicked frantically, though after a few moments bears came and held her legs down. Fluttershy tutted. "Dear dear, Applejack! You seem.... quite exposed." She let out a laugh as Applejack blushed. Fluttershy stopped laughing. She yelled in rage and plunged the sharp glass into Applejack's urine soaked vuvla. Applejack had never felt such pain. She screamed loudly, tears poring down her cheeks as a burning hatred grew inside her for the pony who thought was a friend.