Boyfriend (for girls)

Aries: slenderman

Taurus: Jason the toy maker

Gemini: glitchy red

Cancer: l.j aka laughing jack

Leo: offenderman

Scorpio: jeff the killer

Sagittarius: lost silver

Libra: strangled red

Capricorn: e.j aka eyeless jack

Virgo: puppeteer

Aquarius: ticci toby

Pisces: homicidal liu

If you were wonder guying who would be your bf out of the creepypastas there you go