I've been wanting to do this for a while, so here are my favorite and least favorite songs from all the musicals I listen to! (I'm doing two favorites, one least favorite)
DISCLAIMER: Just because a song is my "least favorite" doesn't mean I dislike it unless I say so
Also don't get mad if I don't like stuff you do

21 Chump Street
Favorite:
What the Heck I Gotta Do?
Cousin
Least favorite:
One School
-Not a bad song, Naomi is just a BITCH

Anastasia
Favorite:
A Rumor In St. Petersburg
In My Dreams
Least favorite:
The Countess and the Common Man
- I just never really liked it that much. It kinda made me uncomfortable

Avenue Q
Favorite:
For Now
Everyone's a Little Bit Racist
Least Favorite:
Fantasies Come True
- Ok, technically I can't really form an opinion because I don't listen to the whole thing. I've only ever heard this one once but I didn't really like it in the bootleg

Be More Chill
Favorite:
Michael in the Bathroom
Voices in My Head
Least favorite:
Do You Wanna Ride/Hang?
- I feel like these can be classified as one song. Either way, they make me uncomfortable

Book of Mormon
Favorite:
You and Me (But Mostly Me)
Man Up
Tomorrow is a Latter Day (I know I said only two but I love all of these songs the same fight me)
Least Favorite:
I Am Here for You
- Just not a big bop. Still a good song though

Dear Evan Hansen
DO CUT SONGS COUNT? They're recorded so I'm gonna say so
Favorite:
Sincerely, Me
Part of Me
Least Favorite:
So Big, So Small
- (don't kill me) Idon'treallylikeRachelBayJones'voicethatmuch

Falsettos
Favorite:
What Would I Do? (It's so pretty okay)
This Had Better Come to a Stop
It's so long I'm giving some honorable mentions
A Tight Knit Family/Love is Blind
Holding to the Ground
Cancelling the Bar Mitzvah (Mendel's vocals are just 👌🏻)
Least Favorite:
Marvin at the Psychiatrist (A Three Part Mini Opera)
- OKAY I LOVE THIS SONG, JUST WANNA GET THAT OUT THERE. I just don't love it as much as I love the others and Part Two makes me uncomfortable

The Greatest Showman
Idk if this counts but Pasek & Paul wrote the soundtrack and they do musicals so I'm saying it does
Favorite:
Rewrite the Stars
Tightrope
Least Favorite:
The Other Side
- It's a good song, I just don't like it as much as the rest and I think the kinda overrated

Hamilton
Favorite:
It's Quiet Uptown (it doesn't make me cry anymore and it's such a pretty song)
The World Was Wide Enough (^^^ and it's just so we'll written and performed)
Again, this one is so damn long it deserves honorable mentions
The Story of Tonight
Satisfied
One Last Time
Non Stop
Who Lives, Who Dies, Who Tells Your Story (was almost at the top, it was the first song I ever heard and it was the reason I listened to it in the first place)
Least Favorite:
We Know
- THIS SONG IS A BOP AND I LOVE IT. But everyone in it is either a bitch (SMFDR) or a dumb bitch (Hamilton)

Heathers
Favorite:
Dead Girl Walking (B a r r e t t)
Meant To Be Yours
Least favorite:
Kindergarten Boyfriend
- ok this song is sooooo overrated and it really makes me uncomfortable. (Don't kill me this is the one I was worried about)

Hedwig and the Angry Inch
Favorite:
Wicked Little Town (Reprise) (YES, THE REPRISE)
When Love Explodes (Love Theme From Hurt Locker: The Musical)
Wig in a Box (Hurt Locker is so short it doesn't even count)
Least Favorite:
The Origin of Love
- I just kinda feel like the whole song is on drugs (not in a good way) and none of the lyrics make any sense and I just don't like it very much

In the Heights
Favorite:
In the Heights
Paciencia Y Fe
(Also Blackout and It Won't Be Long now, but gotta keep it limited)
Least Favorite:
Champagne
- I FUCKING LOVE THIS SONG SO MUCH I CAN'T EVEN THE ONLY REASON IT'S MY LEAST FAVORITE IS BECAUSE USNAVI IS BEING A BITCH LIKE "MY ABUELA JUST DIED BUT I'M GONNA LEAVE MY TINY COUSIN TO FEND FOR HIMSELF AND LEAVE BEHIND THE WOMEN I LOVE BECAUSE I HAVE MONEY THAT COULD BE USED FOR MUCH BETTER THINGS BUT I'M GOING TO THE CARIBBEAN"

Jersey Boys
Favorite:
Cry for Me
Can't Take My Eyes Off of You
Least Favorite:
My Eyes Adored You
- it's an ok song, I just don't really like the way his voice sounds in this one

Kinky Boots
Favorite:
History of Wrong Guys
Soul of a Man (words cannot describe how much I love this song)
Least Favorite:
In This Corner
- idk Don is a bitch and I just don't really like it

Mean Girls
Favorite:
More is Better
World Burn
( Also I'd Rather Be Me and Revenge Party but I can only do two so...)
Least Favorite:
Apex Predator
- don't get me wrong, I love Barrett in this song and it's pretty good. But idk I just feel like it's overrated and it's not my favorite

Newsies
Favorite:
Once and For All
Santa Fe
(Also Carrying the Banner and Brooklyn's Here, the soundtrack is just so good y'all)
Least favorite:
The Bottom Line
- I actually love this song but I love every song from this musical so I pick this one because PULITZER IS A BITCH

The Phantom of the Opera
Here's one I never talk about but yeah it's lit, I saw it live a couple years ago
Favorite:
Down Once More/Track Down This Murderer
The Point of No Return
Least favorite:
I don't really have one I guess?? Prima Donna maybe?
- this is actually one of my favorites but I'm putting it here because "those two fools who run [the Phantom's] theatre" are d u m b

Spring Awakening
Favorite:
And Then There Were None
Left Behind
Least Favorite:
I Believe
- it's an ok song, I just think it's repetitive

Tuck Everlasting
Favorite:
Live Like This
Time Quartet
Least Favorite:
Everything's Golden
- it's a bop but The Man in the Yellow Suit is a BITCH

Waitress
Favorite:
I Love You Like a Table
What Baking Can Do
(Also the first Opening Up)
Least favorite:
You Will Still Be Mine
- I love this song, but Earl is a bitch

Wicked
Another one I never talk about, but it's also great. I saw it two years ago and I'm seeing it again in May (on Broadway!!)
Favorite:
For Good
Defying Gravity
(Super basic choices, I know, but they're good songs ok)
Least Favorite:
A Sentimental Man
- THE WIZARD IS A BITCH

okie dokie there's that.