This is a pretty long part for only some results. Those who are interested, read. I left some tips in the end for the cover makers.

~Here are the round 1 results:

1-thislittlefreak : 4 votes
2-@Spiritmoonz : 4 votes
3-WonderfulNutMeg101 : 4 votes
4-firestar4ever : 3 votes
5-Wolfyfang : 3 votes
6-MysteriousCurl
7-Brambleclaw4Ever : 2 votes
8-@Snowball123 : 2 votes
9-@leopardstar4
10-@CCfairy : 0 votes

Sadly, I must eliminate @CCfairy. Continue your great cover making! A simple contest shouldn't bring you down. I hate eliminating people, but good luck.

Well done thislittlefreak for your first place!

~My own opinion:

In my opinion, I've learned how people dislike or like covers after all my cover making. There was this one cover I worked so hard on and that I found like one of the best I made, but no one left votes, there were no comments and the person I made the cover for disliked it. I kept looking back at it, and for me it looked great! After some more cover making, I realized I simply didn't put enough saturation.

These tiny things change your work from the point of view of others! And I left some tips on the end of this part for the cover makers and the rules on making the judges or anyone like your cover!

I hate choosing between you, but the cover I would choose, if I was Weatherfield Rye, would be either firestar4ever 's or Wolfyfang 's. Both your covers were unique and that's what I'm looking for beyond anything else, and way beyond that. The fact of being unique changes so many things in the people's point of view.

Personally I voted for another cover: Brambleclaw4Ever

You might disagree, but these three were right next to success.

~Tips for making-other-people-like-your-covers:

This is not about how to make your cover. It's about how to make people like your cover. I've realized there's a difference, sadly.

This will be arranged in order of importance. (Except fact 9)

1-You must, in the end of making your cover, click on the button "Autofix". This fixes your errors in the cover and puts some things in evidence. For example your picture is too dark-and you might not realize it when making the cover-the Autofix adds lightness. If you disagree with the Autofix changes, it's a big OK for me. Keep the cover as you wanted it. But, if the Autofix changes the original picture too much, I think you should do something about it.

2-Use Autofix button when you start working on the picture. This changes any default in the picture you chose. This is pretty important because working on a bad picture cannot be easy.

3-Saturation guys, add the saturation to colors. This does not mean add colors, it means make the colors more lively. Never underestimate the Saturation button!

4-Add effects. No seriously, add them. They change your cover, for the best. They make it lively, unique.

5-Don't, no seriously don't add a middle picture as if it's dumped on it. Add a border to it, to make a contrast between the middle picture and the background picture. Also, don't make it too small, it needs to fit in the background picture.

6- Don't splash a color (definition: keeping one color and making the rest black and white), and don't make your cover black and white. You might say "oh but it's cool, it makes the cover mysterious", but for me, it's not done in covers.

7-Font guys, Font. I saw some great fonts out there. Make them unique.

8-I tested you guys in the first round. I wanted to see who would write "A Warrior's Task" or "A warriors task". I was expecting the Capital letters and the apostrophe s in warrior's, not warriors.

9-HUGE WEIRD TIP: each time you finish doing a cover, picture yourself on wattpad on the Discovery tab, typing "Warrior Cat fanfictions". You scroll down the list and a good way down, your book appears with the cover you made.
Now ask yourself: Will the cover catch your eye? Or will you just keep scrolling?
I'm serious, this works. And this is were the whole thing happens. This is were the word unique intervenes more than ever.

If you want me to give constructive criticism on your cover, ask here. But prepare yourself for any negative things. But also good things!

Round two is coming up!