Just so you know, this contains spoilers so skip this chapter if you haven't read Shattered Sky.

So. Onestar, Darktail's father.

I'm 50/50 on this. One paw, it's quite original in the Erin's part. On the other, it's the cliche "my mother and my siblings died and my only living relative hates me." Backstory.

Onestar loving a kittypet is just... I don't know. It just doesn't seem like him. And I'm sure Whitetail was appalled when she found out.

Darktail being evil is also cliche. It's cliche because he's evil because his dad abandoned him.

I have mixed feelings on this.