Jacksepticeye:

Jack had decided that he wanted to play a horror game that actually freaked him out enough to not even sleep. He was a mess.

He would scream if the lights turned off, and you know he wouldn't step foot into the bed unless it was with you. But you somehow managed to calm him down enough and force him to sleep. It was the best sleep of his life.

Antisepticeye:

Anti wasn't scared of anything. Anything but pigeons. Ever since that time in the park he's been on edge that the pigeons were coming to hunt him down for more burgers. He would yell out a deny if you suggested cooking burgers on the outside grill.

Scared the pigeons are watching from the trees. And he says their working for the government. Soon enough, you called him out and said the worst thing they could do to him is poop on his shirt. And Anti finally was relaxed.

Chase:

Chase didn't like the idea of staying outside on a silent night. He swore to you that someone was watching everyone from the forest. You shrugged this off and continue to enjoy the bonfire with your friends. But Chase kept staring at the woods.

And he screamed once he saw yellow eyes staring back. But it turns out, it was just you're friends black cat trailing back home. Making Chase feel a sigh of relief from the small heart attack he had.

Dr. Schneeplestin:

Henrik was very sleep deprived, so much so his work sent him home to get rest. But Henrik refused to sleep. So much so, he started seeing things. He screams from the kitchen, making you come running in. Only seeing Henrik point over at the kitchen closet.

Opening it, it was just some trash bags that fell. "O-Oh," Henrik mumbled. "I guess I do need sleep. I thought someone broke in..." Henrik carefully went to the bedroom to finally get sleep.

Magic Marvin:

For some odd reason, Marvin felt uneasy all day. Like something bad was going to happen to him. So he was contently on edge. So when you came to his show backstage, putting your hand on his shoulder he jumped in surprise and screamed.

Causing him to shoot magic at you. He kept saying sorry as he pushed away all the doves from you, seeing your hair messy and your clothes messed up. "Heh...Sorry..."

Jackaboy-man:

Jackie was having a nightmare. So when he woke up he was on edge when he walked to the bathroom. He lets out a loud scream. You were in the bathroom with a new coconut face mask that you're friend begged you to try.

And you'll admit. You thought he was asleep. "AHHH! A MONSTER! W..W-wait. Oh, it's just you (y/n)..." Jackie breaths. "I thought you were a monster!" He sweats nervously.

Robbie:

Robbie had lost you in a hoard. He was panicking and looking everywhere for you. He was about to start crying before he saw you. Running over. Gripping onto you tightly and saying how scared you had made him. Holding you, masking your scent until the hoard wondered away.

He never let go of you after that for a long time.

Jameson Jackson:

Jameson didn't like today, he was too jumpy, even for his liking. So when you walked up to him while he was reading, the course screamed. But the strange part is that nothing came out.

Only an old-time speech box appearing in front of him reading the word 'FUCK!' You gasped. "Jameson! You cursed!" You tease him, making him bashfully try and say sorry for yelling a curse word. Even though he didn't say anything at all.