She cats paired with him:

Sandstorm
Just, so awesome! She finally realized what she did to Fire star was wrong, and she was simply jealous of Spottedleaf. All she ever tried to do after Spottedleaf's death was help Firestar, for the most part. They are also very cute together.
4.5 stars

Cinderpelt
Why? This ship doesn't make sense! Mentor apprentice relationships are quite gross, and the age difference is just wrong. Its a lot better than Bluestar and Spotted leaf, but Cinderpaw is the only one who had those feelings in the relationship.
1.5 stars

Spottedleaf
Okay, many of us love this ship, but its not my favorite. I think they were kinda cute together, but, just not meant to be. This ship, in my mind, never truly set sail inside the books.
3.5 stars

Bluestar
Ewwwwwwwwww. Who was the mousebrain to create this ship? I mean come on! Yes, she named him after Oakheart, her true love, and she said he always reminded her of him, but gross! She was his mentor, leader, guide, ally, but not mate! Not even close. No cat in this relationship had feelings for each other in that way.
0 stars

What do you think? Who should be with this flame colored leader we all appreciate?